Pete McCutchen wrote:
> Suppose we assume that God is not time-bound (just for the sake of
> argument). Now suppose that, after you were dead, God asked your
> spirit, "OK, was it worth it?" and then refrained from creating you if
> the answer was "no." Would that answer your objection?
No. Because for me to be able to give an answer, I would have had to have
existed somehow, on at least some timeline, even if it's some weird
closed-loop thingy that means I never existed *to anyone else*. (Oh,
where's lojban when you need it?) Saying "can I torture you, then make you
never have existed?" is only a small step away from "can I torture you,
then give you amnesia so you don't remember it?"
_____________________________________________________________________
Susan Stepney tel +44 1223 366343 stepneys@logica.com
Logica UK Ltd, Betjeman House, 104 Hills Road, Cambridge, CB2 1LQ, UK
http://public.logica.com/~stepneys/ http://www.logica.com/