[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: [lojban] RE: Grammar Clarifications



In a message dated 5/28/2001 12:52:55 PM Central Daylight Time,
xod@sixgirls.org writes:



<> That aside
> (incompetence, surely -- why will people take up a logical language and
not
> learn logic?), just why has identity, of all the logical primitives,
fallen
> into disfavor?



Anti-malglico backlash; discomfort with the fact that it can't be tossed
around like "is".>



But, as noted, it CAN be tossed around like the English word "is."  It is
just that doing so is considered 1) very bad style 2) (as in logic classes)
evidence that you don't really understand what you are doing/saying 3) likely
to get you into deep doo-doo in complicated cases.  All of which are true.  
But none of these are reasons to dump {du}, just reasons to learn to use it
(and the rest of the apparatus) correctly.  Without {du} we can't do a large
nuumber of things that any language, but especially a logical langauge, needs
to do.