[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re: ci stedu, and a new dumb idea on quantifiers for people to tear up
>> I think it is partly hinged on the difference between restriction and
>> description. (poi vs. LE) and partly on the bound/free variable distinction.
>> But the arguments get bogged down in terminology and logical analysis and
>> we never get anywhere, so I have stopped trying.
>
>I agree that we shouldn't care about terminology. A few example sentences
>showing the alleged differences is all I ask.
Cowan and I had a longish talk last night on the phone. Funny how things
seem to get clearer at times when we do this. I was able to communicate to
him the differences I felt, and he suddenly had an epiphany. I will have to
write up the reasoning and explanation, but I think we got some useful
answers. Give me a little time.
Cowan BTW is on vacation all this week and off-net.
lojbab