Re: Fwd: Subjunctive?

["Jorge Llambias" <jjllambias@hotmail.com>]

la xod cusku di'e

> > (2) ganai mi ponse lo megdo rupnu gi mi pindi
> >     "Either I don't have a million dollars, or I am poor."
> >
> > That is also true. I don't have a million dollars, so
> > no matter what I put as the second term the sentence
> > will be true.
>
>It's not true in the general case; it does not fit TFTT, as a conditional
>should, because in reality, millionaires are not called poor.

What are you calling the "general case"? There is nothing
general about that sentence, it is about one definite
person and a definite amount of money.

What you seem to be thinking about is something like
"for all x, either x does not have a million dollars
or x is poor". I agree that sentence is false. But
sentence (2) above is true, there is no "general case"
of that sentence unless you start talking about
quantifying over possible worlds or things like that.

>Specifically:
>
>A:"I am a millionaire"  B:"I am poor"   A-->B  (is A-->B really)
>
>          T                   T            T          F
>          T                   F            F          T

A is false, so A->B is true. That's that.

If you are considering cases where A is true, then you are
either talking of a different "I", not me, and therefore
not the same sentence, or you are talking of a different
world, not this real one, where I do have a million dollars.
In either case you need to do something more than the bare
true statement: ganai mi ponse lo megdo rupnu gi mi pindi

co'o mi'e xorxes


______________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free Email at http://www.hotmail.com