[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[lojban-beginners] two epiphanies



doi jbopre poi zmadu mi le ka prije

 

 

  Two things have recently “clicked” with me regarding modals (one  a few weeks ago, and the second just today), and I wanted to make sure I’ve gotten it right, because I never quite “got” this from the CLL

 

1)       Modals are simply another “slot” in the bridi, no less than FA are, and not just a separate thing that just kind of hangs off there in space.  For example, the definition of “mlatu” could have (in some sense) been written “X1 is a cat, forced by BAI, in language BAU, etc….”  (I think what has always confused me here is the way that jbofi’e (at least the web version?) puts a BAI phrase in parentheses, off by itself, so visually isolating it, intead of the way it says, for example, “[zmadu2 exceeded things] :} mi “_

 

1b)  As  such, a BAI slot can go anywhere in a bridi that a FA can, doesn’t have to be off at the end: mi pa klama bai lo ka xagji ku le gusta (I went, compelled by hunger, to the restaurant).

 

2)       Tenses can also act as modals (subject to the caveat in Chap. 10, sect. 23), which is why things like “co’u le nu mi citka kei mi vamtu” (At the end of my eating, I threw up)  work.

 

            2b) (and hence, they too, can appear anywhere any “slot” can appear:  mi pa klama ba le nu mi citka kei le zdanii (“I went, after eating, home”)

 

   And none of these non-numbered slots (BAI, ZAhO, PU, etc.) affect the numbering of non-tagged sumti (the way that members of FA would),  the untagged sumti  just continue getting stuck in where they last left off (or otherwise redirected by FA).

 

   So, have I got this right??  (and I think I just had epiphany number three – this is what the heck is meant by sumti tcita, isn’t it??)

 

                                  --gejyuspa