[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Sapir-Whorf evidence



Tommy Whitlock brought this to my attention, as possible new evidence supporting the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis.

What would be interesting is whether there are detectable brain differences in how adult second language speakers process Mandarin compared to native speakers, which might suggest that different languages might structure our brains differently (in which case one wonders whether a native Lojban speaker would have such differences).

-----------Forwarded message----------
More Brain Power Needed for Mandarin Than English

June 30 - LONDON (Reuters) - Mandarin speakers use more areas of their brains
than people who speak English, scientists said on Monday, in a finding that
provides new insight into how the brain processes language.

Unlike English speakers, who use one side of their brain to understand the
language, scientists at the Wellcome Trust research charity in Britain
discovered that both sides of the brain are used to interpret variations in
sounds in Mandarin. "We were very surprised to discover that people who speak
different sorts of languages use their brains to decode speech in different
ways; it overturned some long-held theories," said Dr. Sophie Scott, a
psychologist at the charity.

Using brain scans on volunteers, Scott discovered that different areas of the
brain are used to interpret words and intonation.

The left temporal lobe of the brain is active when English speakers hear the
language but Mandarin speakers use the left and right lobe, which is normally
used to process melody in music and speech.

Intonation is important in Mandarin because it gives different meanings to the
same word. The word "ma" for example can mean mother, scold, horse or hemp,
depending on the tone.

"We think Mandarin speakers interpret intonation and melody in the right
temporal lobe to give the correct meaning to the spoken word," Scott said in a
statement.

She believes the research could provide insights into what happens when people
are forced to re-learn speech comprehension following a stroke.

"It seems that the structure of the language you learn as a child affects how
the structure of your brain develops to decode speech. Native English
speakers, for example, find it extraordinarily difficult to learn Mandarin,"
Scott said.

The findings will be presented at a science exhibit this week at the Royal
Society, Britain's academy of leading scientists, in London.

--
lojbab                                             lojbab@lojban.org
Bob LeChevalier, Founder, The Logical Language Group
(Opinions are my own; I do not speak for the organization.)
Artificial language Loglan/Lojban:                 http://www.lojban.org