[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
RE: [lojban] the set of answers
Jorge:
> la pycyn cusku di'e
> ><Then {la pol djuno lo du'u makau klama le zarci}>
> ><This is not exactly equivalent to "Paul knows who goes to the store".
> >The English is more specific.>
> >What is inequivalent here? The ellipsis?
>
> The Lojban version allows: {la pol djuno le du'u da klama le zarci}.
>
> I'm not sure that if all Paul knows is that someone goes to the
> store, one can claim in English "Paul knows who goes to the store".
I don't think so.
> The difference I think comes from "who" being more specific than "ma".
In which case the makau locution is rather unsatisfactory, since it
will invariably be making a weaker claim than is usually desired.
--And.